[00:44:19] Chalene Johnson : Well, I started thinking to myself, why is it so many people are very, very comfortable making videos showing their face, myself included, about women who have become what we feel dangerously too thin? But yet, if someone has gained, say, 150 pounds, nobody would dare dream of making a video or suggesting that this person is a role model, and they’re doing a disservice to young women by being overweight.
[00:44:54] Chalene Johnson : And let me tell you that that really made me wonder, like, why is that? Why is it weight gain carries such a strong social taboo? And I think part of it is because obesity has been the target of, like, decades of stigma and discrimination, and people just recognize that criticizing someone for weight gain is cruel.
[00:45:19] Chalene Johnson : That is body shaming. And as a result, like, you know, public figures and brands and creators have been deeply criticized for anything that could be misconstrued as being critical of someone for weight gain. But thinness is culturally idolized in many contexts, so it creates this, like, paradox where people– we celebrate thinness until someone appears too thin, at which point the conversation flips.
[00:45:50] Chalene Johnson : It flips from admiration to alarm. Now, why is that, right? And so the, the message is like, “Oh, you know, anorexia is a deadly disease.” True. But isn’t it interesting that obesity kills four million people a year? Let me say that number again. Four million people a year worldwide. Anorexia kills roughly 40,000, so it’s 100 times more people are likely to die from something related to obesity.
[00:46:24] Chalene Johnson : Yet we feel far more comfortable publicly speculating about thinness than publicly criticizing weight gain. And I think, okay, that makes sense, but the nuance to keep in mind is that And I’m not saying either one is right, but I do notice that there’s an anger in women and the shift that happens where we don’t think of someone when they get too thin as being a victim.
[00:46:57] Chalene Johnson : We don’t think of Ariana as a victim. Suddenly she’s the villain because she’s extremely thin. And why does it happen? I mean, she’s at risk. This is not something she’s probably intended to do. So why does it bring up this, like, anger or this, this reaction? It activates a psychological threat, I think, for women and for myself.
[00:47:20] Chalene Johnson : Like, I’m admitting I have to be aware. Like, why would I have been okay? Why was it okay for me to make a video showing women that were extremely thin? Yet common sense and my understanding of health is such that I know being overweight, not, not even just clinically obese, just being obese, is far more likely to lead to all-cause mortality than being too thin Sure, it could affect your bone density.
[00:47:50] Chalene Johnson : It could affect a lot of different things, but the likelihood of dying from a disease related to obesity is much, much, much higher than simply being too thin. So why is it we feel differently? It’s more acceptable to criticize women when they get too thin. I think that we have to ask ourselves, what does that person’s body say about mine?
[00:48:18] Chalene Johnson : How does it make me feel about my body? And I can’t speak to you and I can’t speak to any other creator. I can only speak about myself. And when I see a woman who has wasted away her muscle and has become way too thin, what it makes me feel like is that I’m supposed to conform to that too, and that somebody wants to control me, and that somebody thinks that whatever weight I’m at, that, like, I’m supposed to be…
[00:48:46] Chalene Johnson : In my subconscious, my subconscious, I think, tells me, “Oh, here you go. You’re gonna fall into that place where I felt so controlled and so criticized and so unhealthy, and nobody cared,” and that everyone kept just saying, “Oh, you look great. Body goals. Can you l- lose a few more pounds?” And it makes me feel this, like, anger and rage and threat.
[00:49:08] Chalene Johnson : And I think it’s just easier to tolerate anger than it is to tolerate inadequacy. Because if I’m being all the way honest, when I was in the consumer fitness space, I felt inadequate. I felt like, because I was being told it wasn’t enough, like I- you, you need to do more. And so when I see bodies like that, it can trigger that same feeling, like, “Oh, you’re not gonna be successful.
[00:49:39] Chalene Johnson : People are gonna see you as undisciplined. People are gonna see you as undesirable.” And then it’s easier and it’s more socially acceptable to say, “I’m worried about this person. We’re worried about her health.” And it’s like it’s a moral high ground to say, “We’re worried about her.” When we place it under the umbrella of care and concern, and we’re like, “Oh, she looks terrible,” or, “This is, this is just so dangerous,” it puts us in this, like, position of, like, a moral high ground, like a sense of superiority, right?
[00:50:12] Chalene Johnson : The reason why I think we only see, primarily, we- I shouldn’t say only, but primarily we see women talking about other women’s bodies, especially other women who’ve gotten dramatically thin, and especially related to the GLP-1 era, is that some women experience it as Like the power quietly abandoning this agreement that we all had.
[00:50:34] Chalene Johnson : Like girls, we’re sticking together, right? Like we’re not, we’re not gonna let society do this to us again, right? We’re not gonna let the patriarchy, we’re not gonna let the manosphere tell us that we need to be thin and insignificant and invisible. And so there’s this like perception that one of these stars or someone we know is like betraying us.
[00:50:55] Chalene Johnson : Like wait, why are you giving into this? Why are we making extreme thinness the mark of beauty? And I think I just have to say this, that does not mean that when you express concern over somebody that it’s fake or that it comes from a place of anger or it’s because it- their weight makes you feel inadequate.
[00:51:16] Chalene Johnson : That’s certainly not true. I mean, there have been people in my life who I can tell you it had nothing to do with me feeling inadequate. It was genuine concern for their health, their mental health, their wellbeing because 40,000 people who die every year of anorexia is nothing to sneeze at. And some women have a very personal experience with anorexia.
[00:51:40] Chalene Johnson : You, you can recog- I can recognize warning signs of eating disorders. I can see them. I can smell them. I can sniff it out in other people. I, I can see another orthorexia. I can see disordered eating. I c- I can see warning signs. Sometimes it is concerning and sometimes it’s just like, oh, I just kinda like note it and I, I realize like, okay, I’m, I’m noting it, but is this person truly in danger or does it bother me?
[00:52:09] Chalene Johnson : I mean, there’s like a few people who I know peripherally who I have known for years that they have disordered eating. They have a very unhealthy relationship with food and their bodies, and it’s weird. Those people, for the most part, I just… Like it doesn’t feel like that’s a threat to me But if I’m being honest, when it’s, like, a celebrity, it does sometimes trigger this subconscious belief that this is the expectation for all of us, that, like, it, it’s coming for me, and soon I’m gonna be criticized.
[00:52:47] Chalene Johnson : I’m, I’m gonna go to the audition, and I’m, I’m gonna be told I’m not good enough. And I’ve had the opposite happen. I’ve had… I mean, I remember when I would go to these events for Beachbody, and there’d be, you know, thousands of people, and they’d take pictures with each one of the trainers. And so often people thought they were giving you a compliment on your body, and they just didn’t even realize what they were saying was so hurtful.
[00:53:17] Chalene Johnson : They didn’t realize how it sounded. Like, they would go, “You know what? I love you. I love you because you’re not super thin like so-and-so.” And you’d be like, “Okay, I know that was meant as a compliment, but in my brain, I just heard you call me fat.” I was riding in an elevator down to teach one of the workouts for, like, thousands of people, right?
[00:53:41] Chalene Johnson : And so we’re in this packed elevator, and I was, like, kind of crammed in the back. And I’m also 5’2″, so, you know, no one can see me. And the elevator was crammed, and there was, uh, women in the front, and they were discussing how they had seen me in one of the workouts, and they were so excited to talk about the fact that they saw cellulite on the back of my thighs.
[00:54:05] Chalene Johnson : And they were like, “That was such a relief.” And I was like, wow. They didn’t know I was in the elevator, and I know they meant that as a positive, but they also were talking about somebody else’s body, another trainer’s body, who didn’t have cellulite. And, and I know they were saying, like, how it was so, it was such a relief to see that I, quote, “wasn’t perfect.”
[00:54:28] Chalene Johnson : But I’m standing in this, back of this elevator going, “See? You don’t belong.” Like, girl, what are you– why are you in the front of all these people teaching these workouts when you have cellulite? Do you see what I’m s- Like, it’s just women’s bodies, oh, they’re never, ever good enough. And I can’t speak on behalf of Black women or brown women, but I have enough Black girlfriends, and we’ve talked about the difference in the way women who, you know, their Black girlfriends talk about weight, and how white girls talk about weight.
[00:55:03] Chalene Johnson : And when it… A- and I mean, for most young white women, it’s around age five that you feel like, “Oh, I better go on a diet.” I mean, if you ask most women, they remember being awa- white women being aware that they need to be smaller by about age five. All this to say that I think that women are not only afraid that extreme thinness is something that means that person is unwell, right?
[00:55:33] Chalene Johnson : I think we are also reacting to how other people’s bodies make us feel about our own. So then how do we explain when, when trolls do make comments about women who have gained weight, or women who are curvier and on the runway? How do we explain that? Well, first of all, if you look at those comments, so many of them are men.
[00:55:58] Chalene Johnson : A lot more than the comments that are rude about being ultra-thin. That says a lot. Secondly, I think that it is a case of punching up. Are you familiar with that term? When we see someone who we think is better than us, that we’re jealous of, who’s more beautiful, has more followers, is walking the runway, is rocking millions and millions of followers on TikTok or Instagram and, and you’re not, their success makes you feel inadequate, makes some people feel inadequate.
[00:56:32] Chalene Johnson : So then to see any type of a flaw or a crack in the surface of perfection, it’s an opportunity to make themselves feel better by poking fun, by picking them apart, by criticizing them. So for the moment, that person might feel a little bit better about themselves. Like, “Hey, let me just point out to the world that this person is imperfect by somebody’s standards.”
[00:56:59] Chalene Johnson : I’m sure you’re familiar with the phrase, confident people inspire, insecure people compete. Happy people compliment, unhappy people criticize. Hurt people hurt people. Healed people help people. Happy people don’t have time to hate, they’re too busy enjoying their own lives. Anyways, I’m just trying to be self-aware.
[00:57:21] Chalene Johnson : I’m not perfect. I’m very catty. I’m still gonna gossip with my girlfriends about so-and-so’s body. I’m going to. I just am. I am that . And I’m gonna say, “Oh my God, did you see her? Wow, she’s not looking too good.” I’m gonna say that with my girlfriends, okay? Because I’m, I’m a girl. It is part of the way that we make sense of what is healthy and what’s unhealthy and what’s acceptable and what’s unacceptable.
[00:57:48] Chalene Johnson : Like, uh, and I think that’s okay. But what’s not okay is public commentary on my behalf, in my opinion. I, I’ve just… I don’t… at the moment, I don’t plan on commenting about women’s bodies without more context, because we cannot deny the fact that obesity kills a hell of a lot more people than anorexia, ultra-thinness.
[00:58:17] Chalene Johnson : And we don’t necessarily know that anyone who’s ultra-thin has anorexia per se. They might just be thinner than what makes us comfortable. Yes, anorexia is exceptionally deadly. I, you know, don’t wanna gloss over that. And if you think you are Or someone you love is suffering, I’m gonna put some information down below of resources where you can reach out for help.
[00:58:48] Chalene Johnson : But we cannot gloss over the fact that obesity related diseases claim roughly 100 times more lives every year, because obesity affects so many more people. You know, and yes, I, I know that anorexia has one of the highest mortality rates of mental illnesses, but obesity related complications kill far more people each year.
[00:59:14] Chalene Johnson : And, and that we know. So I’m not saying either is good. I’m just saying I wanna be more self… I’m trying to be more aware of why it makes us feel a certain way and why people, especially women, are triggered when other women lose weight. And I think it also explains why there’s this weird anger that some people have around GLP-1s.
[00:59:41] Chalene Johnson : And there’s this like, it’s strange, that’s dividing us too. I don’t like that. I don’t like that. Anyways, what do you think about all of this? I’m sure I got a lot of this wrong. I’m sure you’ve got some opinions, and I’d love to hear them, as long as you’re nice about it. Like, use good manners. Leave your comments wherever you listen to the show.
[01:00:01] Chalene Johnson : You can leave them on Spotify. You can leave them inside the Patreon app. I have so many other things I was supposed to talk to you about today, like major things that are happening in the news that impact you. So please tune in on Friday, because I’m gonna fit some of those in on Friday, and I’m sure some new things will happen in between then.
[01:00:17] Chalene Johnson : But again, in the meantime, share your thoughts with me. I love you. I mean it, and I will talk to you soon.